Today is the day—Sloan‘s tenth studio album in their twenty years together as a band is available now, and it’s a goodie. While you’ll need to make some time to dig into the twelve brand new tracks from Chris Murphy, Patrick Pentland, Jay Ferguson, and Andrew Scott on The Double Cross, the latest in a series of tribute videos is all about the past.

Joel Plaskett, Sebastian Grainger, The Dears, and more, dish on their favourite Sloan songs of all time, and the die-hards among us might be pleasantly surprised to see a number of deep album cuts make these lists.